---
title: "Senator Spellman — Balance the Budget"
description: "The bill cuts defense spending by 30% through contract repricing, adds income, capital gains and very-high-income surtaxes, raises oil company and IRS…"
url: "https://www.balance-the-budget.finance/leaderboard/3440b9b4707d"
updated: "2026-11-14"
---

# Senator Spellman’s bill

C

Grade earned

Now we're talking.

Senate vote

52-48, passed

Closed

$807.3B (40.5%)

After

$1.19T

Posted

Nov 14, 2026

Scored against the Incoming Senate (120th Congress, seated Jan 3, 2027). Roster incoming-v1, data fy2026-v7.

The bill cuts defense spending by 30% through contract repricing, adds income, capital gains and very-high-income surtaxes, raises oil company and IRS enforcement taxes and funding, and repeals Public Law 119-21 (the 2025 reconciliation law). Several parts, including the gas price cap, loophole removal, state police penalties, property taxes and statehood, are too vague or not federal budget items.

[Back to the Hall of Almost](https://www.balance-the-budget.finance/leaderboard)

## The bill

```
Cut defense by 30% primarily through reevaluating the cost of defense contracts that are being overcharged by private contractors and causing extreme bloat. Effective spending remains the same but at a lower, correct cost. Increase individual income tax for people making $300,000 combined household income by 2%. Increase individual income tax for people making $1,000,000 combined household income by 10%. Increase capital gains and dividends tax for gains over $1,000,000 by 10%. A wealth tax that taxes all household income over $1,000,000,000 (cap gains, dividends, salary, any type of income or wealth generation) an additional 20%. Increase corporate income tax rates for oil companies by 10% while putting a cap on gas price hikes so that these companies cannot make up for lesser profits by over charging. Increase IRS spending by 50% but in doing so increase their efficiency at hunting down individual and corporate tax avoidance. Remove loopholes that allow individuals or corporations to avoid taxes if those taxes would be over $1,000,000. Limit the ability take out loans against debt for ultra wealthy individuals. Implement a tax for private plane travel via increase fuel rates. Hold aside some of federal budget that goes to state police and impose penalties to departments that see high volumes of behavioral conduct issues and indictments. Increase property taxes for home owners who do not spend the majority of their year living at the residence. Repeal the big beautiful bill. Submarine capacity will largely remain untouched and veterans care will be fully protected. Rural health coverage and Arctic defense will be preserved, part of the Arctic defense will also be further sanctions to Russia. Give Puerto Rico and DC statehood. A yacht tax for parking or operating private yacht-class boats in American ports.
```

Opens in your editor so you can change it first.

## Roll call

Yes 52Need 51No 48

AK

ME

VT

NH

WA

ID

MT

ND

MN

IL

WI

MI

NY

RI

MA

OR

NV

WY

SD

IA

IN

OH

PA

NJ

CT

CA

UT

CO

NE

MO

KY

WV

VA

MD

DE

AZ

NM

KS

AR

TN

NC

SC

OK

LA

MS

AL

GA

HI

TX

FL

Tap a tile to read that senator’s vote.

Two tiles per state, one per senator. Read-only.

## Before and after

#### Before

Revenue

$5.40T

Spending

$7.40T

#### After

Revenue

$6.04T

Spending

$7.22T

- Individual income taxes
- Payroll taxes
- Corporate income taxes
- Customs
- Other revenue
- Social Security
- Medicare
- Medicaid
- Defense
- Net interest
- Veterans
- Income security
- Federal workforce
- Health
- Domestic programs

Deficit**$1.19T**

The hole: $1.99T. One block = 5% of it.

## What it changed

Line

Before

After

Change

Revenue

Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

$2.45T

$2.99T

+$541B

Individual income tax: capital gains and dividends

$394B

$424B

+$30B

Corporate income tax

$382B

$432B

+$50B

Excise taxes

$95B

$98B

+$3B

Estate and gift taxes

$30B

$38B

+$8B

Spending

Medicaid

$723B

$808B

+$85B

National defense

$958B

$703B

−$255B

Net interest on the debt

$1.16T

$1.13T

−$27.3B

SNAP (food assistance)

$100B

$118B

+$18B

ACA marketplace subsidies

$90B

$105B

+$15B

Homeland security and immigration enforcement

$85B

$68B

−$17B

All other government operations

$79B

$85B

+$6B

## How each part scored

- **Cut defense 30% via contract repricing**−$240B per year on National defense

  A 30% cut phased in, scaled from the 10% anchor with diminishing returns because contract repricing is unlikely to capture the full amount. Confidence 25%.
- **Income tax +2 points above $300,000 household income**+$65B per year on Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

  Read as 2 percentage points on income above $300,000, with behavioral response. Confidence 40%.
- **Income tax +10 points above $1,000,000 household income**+$110B per year on Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

  Read as 10 percentage points on income above $1M, scaled from the surtax anchors with heavy avoidance. Confidence 35%.
- **Capital gains and dividend tax +10 points on gains over $1M**+$25B per year on Individual income tax: capital gains and dividends

  Large realization response reduces yield well below 10 times the 1-point anchor. Confidence 35%.
- **Extra 20% tax on income over $1 billion**+$12B per year on Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

  Very few households qualify and avoidance is high, so yield is small. Confidence 15%.
- **Oil company corporate tax +10 points**+$10B per year on Corporate income tax

  Applies to roughly $150B of oil sector taxable profit with a behavioral response. Confidence 30%.
- **IRS funding +50% (revenue)**+$14B per year on Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

  About $6B of added funding yields roughly $14B of extra collections. Confidence 30%.
- **IRS funding +50% (spending)**+$6B per year on All other government operations

  IRS budget of about $12B rises by half. Confidence 40%.
- **Limit borrowing against assets by ultra wealthy**+$5B per year on Individual income tax: capital gains and dividends

  Narrow limit on buy-borrow-die strategies, scored as a fraction of the step-up in basis anchor. Confidence 15%.
- **Private plane fuel tax increase**+$2B per year on Excise taxes

  Roughly $1 per gallon added on private jet fuel use of about 1.5B gallons. Confidence 20%.
- **Yacht tax**+$1B per year on Excise taxes

  Small base of yacht-class vessels with a modest fee. Confidence 15%.
- **Repeal Public Law 119-21: individual tax provisions**+$340B per year on Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

  Reverses individual tax cuts, SALT, tips and overtime, and TCJA extensions at roughly $3.4T over 10 years. Confidence 30%.
- **Repeal Public Law 119-21: business expensing**+$40B per year on Corporate income tax

  Reverses bonus depreciation and R&D expensing per the anchor range. Confidence 35%.
- **Repeal Public Law 119-21: estate exemption**+$8B per year on Estate and gift taxes

  Restores the lower pre-2025 estate tax exemption. Confidence 30%.
- **Repeal Public Law 119-21: Medicaid cuts reversed**+$85B per year on Medicaid

  Restores about $850B of ten-year Medicaid reductions. Confidence 35%.
- **Repeal Public Law 119-21: SNAP cuts reversed**+$18B per year on SNAP (food assistance)

  Restores about $180B of ten-year SNAP reductions. Confidence 35%.
- **Repeal Public Law 119-21: ACA changes reversed**+$15B per year on ACA marketplace subsidies

  Restores marketplace eligibility and verification changes. Confidence 25%.
- **Repeal Public Law 119-21: defense additions removed**−$15B per year on National defense

  Removes about $150B of ten-year added defense funding. Confidence 35%.
- **Repeal Public Law 119-21: homeland security additions removed**−$17B per year on Homeland security and immigration enforcement

  Removes about $170B of ten-year added immigration enforcement and border funding. Confidence 35%.
