---
title: "Seth — Balance the Budget"
description: "The bill repeals the 2025 reconciliation law (P.L. 119-21) and cuts defense by 30%. It also removes the Social Security payroll tax cap without adding…"
url: "https://www.balance-the-budget.finance/leaderboard/b78131c93bb0"
updated: "2026-11-14"
---

# Seth’s bill

B

Grade earned

Seriously impressive.

Senate vote

53-47, passed

Closed

$1.26T (63.2%)

After

$733.4B

Posted

Nov 14, 2026

Scored against the Incoming Senate (120th Congress, seated Jan 3, 2027). Roster incoming-v1, data fy2026-v7.

The bill repeals the 2025 reconciliation law (P.L. 119-21) and cuts defense by 30%. It also removes the Social Security payroll tax cap without adding benefits, replaces the employer payroll taxes with an uncapped 7.65% tax on all compensation, adds a 45% bracket above $200,000, ends stepped-up basis at death, and requires alternative depreciation for investment. Finally, it reverts the estate tax to Clinton-era rules and eliminates the SALT deduction. The net effect is a large deficit reduction.

[Back to the Hall of Almost](https://www.balance-the-budget.finance/leaderboard)

## The bill

```
Repeal the Big Beautiful Bill Cut Military spending by 30% by reevaluating existing bloated and fraudulent contracts without impacting readiness or long term investment remove the payroll tax cap without removing the social security formula salary cap Create a new 45% tax bracket over $200,000 End Stepped up basis for capital gains at death Replace current employer-sided payroll taxes for social security and medicare with a 7.65% tax on employer compensation, with no salary cap require the use of the alternateive depreciation schedule instead of the modified accelerated cost recovery system for all investment depreciation deductions Revert the estate tax to how it was during the clinton administration Eliminate the SALT Deduction
```

Opens in your editor so you can change it first.

## Roll call

Yes 53Need 51No 47

AK

ME

VT

NH

WA

ID

MT

ND

MN

IL

WI

MI

NY

RI

MA

OR

NV

WY

SD

IA

IN

OH

PA

NJ

CT

CA

UT

CO

NE

MO

KY

WV

VA

MD

DE

AZ

NM

KS

AR

TN

NC

SC

OK

LA

MS

AL

GA

HI

TX

FL

Tap a tile to read that senator’s vote.

Two tiles per state, one per senator. Read-only.

## Before and after

#### Before

Revenue

$5.40T

Spending

$7.40T

#### After

Revenue

$6.47T

Spending

$7.20T

- Individual income taxes
- Payroll taxes
- Corporate income taxes
- Customs
- Other revenue
- Social Security
- Medicare
- Medicaid
- Defense
- Net interest
- Veterans
- Income security
- Federal workforce
- Health
- Domestic programs

Deficit**$733.4B**

The hole: $1.99T. One block = 5% of it.

## What it changed

Line

Before

After

Change

Revenue

Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

$2.45T

$3.00T

+$545B

Individual income tax: capital gains and dividends

$394B

$429B

+$35B

Social Security payroll tax

$1.34T

$1.63T

+$285B

Medicare payroll tax

$405B

$420B

+$15B

Corporate income tax

$382B

$477B

+$95B

Estate and gift taxes

$30B

$120B

+$90B

Spending

Medicaid

$723B

$808B

+$85B

National defense

$958B

$718B

−$240B

Net interest on the debt

$1.16T

$1.12T

−$42.6B

SNAP (food assistance)

$100B

$118B

+$18B

Homeland security and immigration enforcement

$85B

$70B

−$15B

## How each part scored

- **Repeal the 2025 reconciliation law (P.L. 119-21): individual tax provisions**+$240B per year on Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

  Reverting to pre-2025 law for individual rates, deductions and credits, excluding SALT, which is scored separately, and trimmed for overlap with the new 45% bracket. Confidence 35%.
- **Repeal the 2025 reconciliation law: business tax provisions (R&D expensing, interest limit, international)**+$25B per year on Corporate income tax

  Bonus depreciation is scored in the alternative depreciation provision, so this covers only the remaining business provisions. Confidence 30%.
- **Repeal the 2025 reconciliation law: Medicaid cuts reversed**+$85B per year on Medicaid

  Repeal reverses roughly $0.9 trillion of ten-year Medicaid savings, phased in over the decade. Confidence 40%.
- **Repeal the 2025 reconciliation law: SNAP cuts reversed**+$18B per year on SNAP (food assistance)

  Repeal reverses roughly $180 billion of ten-year SNAP savings. Confidence 40%.
- **Repeal the 2025 reconciliation law: border and immigration enforcement funding removed**−$15B per year on Homeland security and immigration enforcement

  Removes the law's multi-year enforcement funding, with outlays spread over the decade. Confidence 35%.
- **Cut military spending by 30%**−$240B per year on National defense

  A 30% cut would be about -$287B, scaled from the 10% anchor, with a haircut for diminishing returns and slow outlays, assuming savings come from contract reductions. Confidence 40%.
- **Remove the Social Security payroll tax cap with no new benefits**+$225B per year on Social Security payroll tax

  The 12.4% tax applies to all earnings, covering both employer and employee shares, while the benefit formula keeps its current cap. Confidence 65%.
- **New 45% bracket on income over $200,000**+$230B per year on Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

  Ordinary income above $200,000 is taxed at 45% instead of 24-37%, with about a one-third behavioral and avoidance offset. Confidence 35%.
- **End stepped-up basis for capital gains at death**+$35B per year on Individual income tax: capital gains and dividends

  Fully phased in, with carryover basis and standard reference estimates. Confidence 55%.
- **Employer 7.65% tax on all compensation with no cap: Social Security share**+$60B per year on Social Security payroll tax

  Only the base broadening to non-wage compensation such as health and retirement benefits is counted here, since cap removal is scored separately. Confidence 30%.
- **Employer 7.65% tax on all compensation with no cap: Medicare share**+$15B per year on Medicare payroll tax

  The Medicare portion of the broadened base is about 19% of the 7.65% rate. Confidence 30%.
- **Require alternative depreciation (ADS) for all investment: corporate**+$70B per year on Corporate income tax

  Eliminates bonus depreciation and MACRS acceleration, with timing effects that shrink over the ten-year window. Confidence 35%.
- **Require alternative depreciation (ADS) for all investment: pass-through and individual**+$15B per year on Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

  Noncorporate businesses lose accelerated deductions, giving a smaller share of the total. Confidence 30%.
- **Revert estate tax to Clinton-era rules**+$90B per year on Estate and gift taxes

  An exemption of about $650,000 and a 55% top rate, uninflated, applied to today's much larger estates, versus the current $15 million exemption. Confidence 35%.
- **Eliminate the SALT deduction**+$60B per year on Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

  Eliminates the $40,000-capped deduction, using the standard reference range. Confidence 55%.
