---
title: "Seth — Balance the Budget"
description: "The bill overhauls business taxation (no corporate interest deduction or interest income tax, plus a destination-based cash flow tax), removes the Social…"
url: "https://www.balance-the-budget.finance/leaderboard/b7ff156c8fbb"
updated: "2026-11-14"
---

# Seth’s bill

C

Would have earned

Now we're talking.

Senate vote

50-50, failed

Closed

$951.2B (47.7%)

After

$1.04T

Posted

Nov 14, 2026

Scored against the Incoming Senate (120th Congress, seated Jan 3, 2027). Roster incoming-v1, data fy2026-v7.

The bill overhauls business taxation (no corporate interest deduction or interest income tax, plus a destination-based cash flow tax), removes the Social Security payroll tax cap without adding benefits, and reverses the individual income tax changes in Public Law 119-21. It also repeals most tariffs, adds a 10% VAT with a rebate, cuts Medicare drug and Medicare Advantage spending, and adds agricultural and rural hospital aid.

[Back to the Hall of Almost](https://www.balance-the-budget.finance/leaderboard)

## The bill

```
Reverse treatment of corporate interest, no deduction for corporate interest payments and no tax on corporate interest income. Enact a destination based cash flow tax. Remove the payroll tax cap but limit social seculrity benefits to the existing pay cap. Allow medicare to negotiate for prescription drugs. Revert the Big Beautiful Bill changes to individual income taxes. Repeal trump tariffs, except for those on steel, and require congressional approval for new tariffs. Enact a 10% Value Added Tax, phased in over 5 years with exemptions for businesses with less than 500,000 in revenue, and provide a rebate equivalent to the average consumption tax bill a middle class household would pay under the VAT, phase out evenly between the poverty line and 100,000 of income. Reduce payment rates for Medicare Advantage. Direct the president to negotiate for bilateral tariff reductions prioritizing farm exports and create a $10 billion a year program to provide relief to agricultural exporters harmed by the trade war. Increase funding by 10 billion a year for distressed rural and tribal hospitals.
```

Opens in your editor so you can change it first.

## Roll call

Yes 50Need 51No 50

AK

ME

VT

NH

WA

ID

MT

ND

MN

IL

WI

MI

NY

RI

MA

OR

NV

WY

SD

IA

IN

OH

PA

NJ

CT

CA

UT

CO

NE

MO

KY

WV

VA

MD

DE

AZ

NM

KS

AR

TN

NC

SC

OK

LA

MS

AL

GA

HI

TX

FL

Tap a tile to read that senator’s vote.

Two tiles per state, one per senator. Read-only.

## Before and after

#### Before

Revenue

$5.40T

Spending

$7.40T

#### After

Revenue

$6.46T

Spending

$7.50T

- Individual income taxes
- Payroll taxes
- Corporate income taxes
- Customs
- Other revenue
- Social Security
- Medicare
- Medicaid
- Defense
- Net interest
- Veterans
- Income security
- Federal workforce
- Health
- Domestic programs

Deficit**$1.04T**

The hole: $1.99T. One block = 5% of it.

## What it changed

Line

Before

After

Change

Revenue

Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

$2.45T

$2.87T

+$420B

Social Security payroll tax

$1.34T

$1.56T

+$215B

Corporate income tax

$382B

$462B

+$80B

Tariffs and customs duties

$173B

$33B

−$140B

Excise taxes

$95B

$575B

+$480B

Spending

Medicare

$1.04T

$1.00T

−$34B

Net interest on the debt

$1.16T

$1.13T

−$32.2B

Refundable tax credits (EITC, child credit)

$160B

$320B

+$160B

Agriculture and farm subsidies

$45B

$55B

+$10B

## How each part scored

- **Corporate interest: end deduction and exempt interest income**+$40B per year on Corporate income tax

  Denying the interest deduction raises about $100B/yr, and exempting corporate interest income offsets over half of that. Confidence 25%.
- **Destination-based cash flow tax (border adjustment, expensing)**+$40B per year on Corporate income tax

  Border adjustment on the trade deficit nets of full expensing, reduced for overlap with the VAT and the interest provision, and no rate cut is assumed. Confidence 20%.
- **Remove Social Security payroll tax cap**+$215B per year on Social Security payroll tax

  All earnings are taxed at 12.4% with some avoidance and reduced earnings. Confidence 55%.
- **Limit Social Security benefits to existing cap (no new benefits)**$0B per year on Social Security

  Benefits stay calculated on current-law earnings, so there is no added spending and no savings. Confidence 60%.
- **Medicare drug price negotiation expansion**−$17B per year on Medicare

  Negotiation is expanded to more drugs at the standard reference level. Confidence 50%.
- **Revert PL 119-21 individual income tax changes**+$420B per year on Individual income tax: wages and ordinary income

  TCJA rates, deductions and credits expire and the new deductions for tips, overtime, seniors and the higher SALT cap are repealed. Confidence 40%.
- **Revert PL 119-21 individual income tax changes (refundable child credit)**−$20B per year on Refundable tax credits (EITC, child credit)

  The child tax credit returns to its lower pre-reconciliation level, which reduces refundable outlays. Confidence 35%.
- **Repeal Trump tariffs except steel**−$140B per year on Tariffs and customs duties

  Roughly $30B/yr of tariff revenue remains, from steel and some older duties, and the rest of the $173B baseline is lost. Confidence 40%.
- **10% VAT phased in over 5 years with small business exemption**+$480B per year on Excise taxes

  The reference 5% VAT yields $250-300B, doubled for a 10% rate, then trimmed for the small-business exemption, avoidance and the phase-in. Confidence 35%.
- **VAT rebate to households (phased out from poverty line to $100,000)**+$180B per year on Refundable tax credits (EITC, child credit)

  The rebate is a refundable credit equal to the average middle-class VAT bill and phases out evenly, costing about 35-40% of VAT revenue. Confidence 30%.
- **Reduce Medicare Advantage payment rates**−$27B per year on Medicare

  The standard reference proposal of lower benchmark payments is assumed. Confidence 45%.
- **Agricultural exporter trade relief program**+$10B per year on Agriculture and farm subsidies

  $10B per year is fully spent as stated. Confidence 85%.
- **Distressed rural and tribal hospital funding**+$10B per year on Medicare

  The $10B per year is delivered mainly through Medicare-type payments and is fully spent. Confidence 55%.
